The Value of Facebook

Connecting to my world on Facebook

Is Facebook worth more than $30 a share?  We will find out tomorrow and more importantly, in the days to come.  But it’s been worth a lot to me, so the question of what the value of Facebook is in our society now is quite interesting.  I thought today would be a good moment to explain its value to me.

“I don’t do FB.”  I hear this a lot, even though there are now over 900  million Facebook users so I am kind of wondering why I know so many hold-outs (besides my mom, I mean).  I usually respond, cautiously, that Facebook is essential these days, a social utility like the telephone.  And that means it is worth quite a lot. Why?

The word “friends” is a misnomer that confuses a lot of people who distrust the Facebook world.  How could you have 200 or 500 “friends”? My Facebook contacts are not a list of my friends – I am not equally close or intimate with all the people to whom I am connected.  But it is a genuine community of real people who know me, inside of which are different but overlapping circles of family, close and casual friends, colleagues from a variety of jobs and activities, neighbors from several homes, and classmates from various schools.  That reflects normal life pretty well, doesn’t it?

Facebook has become particularly useful when you are in transition – between homes, jobs, schools, travels around the world, anywhere you’ve created a circle of people don’t want to leave behind.  It’s great that it is global when, like me, you’ve lived in lots of different places.  Email – well, it just takes too much time to stay in touch with more than a few people, and who likes getting emails with large cc lists? Not all that personal really.

I left a job a year ago. In a flash I lost access to the email listserve with hundreds of colleagues with whom I had worked for years.  Not my first job transition. But this one has been very different. Through Facebook for the first time, I found myself in easy touch with many of the people with whom I used to have lunch and share jokes.  We still exchange shoptalk and rib each other, in real time.  When someone in my FB world has a big announcement – a new boss, a baby, a retirement, an event, or a birthday, I hear about it and see the photos.  When I do see or call them, it is much easier to pick up the conversation because I know they’ve been on vacation to Cabo, gotten a dog or changed jobs.  I even got invited to and kept track of my high school reunion in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia.

When I got sick last year, I could keep up with what my family, friends, and colleagues were doing even when I wasn’t getting around a lot.  I could check in on the antics of various young relatives, though I try not to comment on their pages!  When I finally told my FB friends that I had breast cancer (partly because it was getting hard to remember who I had told privately), I got an amazing flow of supportive messages from all over my world.  People kept track of my progress in private messages, visits and comments. Now that I am fine and back working, Facebook offers an easy way to pick up conversations, exchange messages, and search for people with whom I have lost contact.  It is quite efficient and definitely not a waste of time.  You put into it what you need, and you get out of it what you put into it.

That’s why when people say, “I don’t do Facebook,” I respond, “You should try it, it works.”  What I don’t say is why do you want to be left out, when you too will go through these normal transitions in life and this kind of new social media allows you to carry your relationships with you?  What is more valuable than your network?

So, Mark Zuckerberg, are you worth all the money the market is throwing at you in this IPO?  We’ll see over the long term, whatever that is in a social media world.  But thanks a lot for making possible these conversations, photo and news sharing with my family and friends.  Just remember please two things as Facebook grows:  privacy does matter, and so does doing good.  We look forward to seeing how this story will play out.

Posted in Communications, Facebook, Innovation, Social media, Uncategorized | Leave a comment

Who Killed Z?

Unfilled, expensive but needed and effective drug prescriptions were found among her things.  Eligibility for the $1,000 Cobra payments had ended long before.  She last saw a therapist a few months before this sad day, though she wanted to continue.

A bright young woman who launched into real estate in Washington DC just as the market crashed, she found that “preexisting condition” meant U.S. health insurance was hundreds of dollars out of reach.  Suffering from a deep but treatable depression, stemming from horrifying traumas, she took one long look at the future and bowed out.  She couldn’t afford to live, and without help, life was not worth living. Methodically she wound up her affairs, wrote a will, organized her papers, wrote letters to friends and family, put her beloved little dog. in a kennel, and lay down to die.  She wasn’t found for many days.

I won’t give you her real name, because her family in Minnesota was devastated, as were her friends around the world.  Z loved purple, dancing, shopping, mint juleps, and international anything. She worked all over the world and spoke Japanese and German. She was the life of the party until she wasn’t.  She had a good job with health insurance but a difficult situation made her leave.  This being America, the home of the free and the brave, she never found affordable health insurance again. The awful news is that if Z had lived in Canada, she might still be alive.

So back to our question:  Who killed Z?  Well, we all did.  By accepting the political paralysis that besets our country, by not protesting the obvious fallacies in the arguments of slick politicians who all have great health care insurance, we let this happen.  More will come after Z, many preceded her.  The unemployed, the independent contractors, the consultants, the “preexisting conditions” tribe, all of them at risk if Congress succeeds in rolling back Obamacare.

Raise your hand if you have relatives without health care.  I have. And dear friends like Z?  I have. Raise your hand if you have ever paid for one of them to have health insurance because you were so worried.  I have.  Raise your hand if you would refuse if you were asked to help pay for a life-saving procedure for one of your nearest and dearest. I truly don’t know. For hospitalization when one of them had what we quaintly used to call a nervous breakdown?  For an accident?  Cancer?

Where exactly do you draw the line? How much money can you spare?  How long can you afford to help?  What jacked-up rates will you have to pay on their behalf since they don’t qualify for your low insured rate?

When does love run out? In Z’s case, it ran out in February 2011.  This is a real story.  I share it because it is also the second anniversary of the Affordable Health Care Act.  We should think about who we want to be as a country, and when we do, we should think about Z and all the people we love.

Posted in Health | Tagged , , , | 2 Comments

Five Reasons to Come to the Yucatan

Five reasons to come to the Yucatan if you are recovering from illness or, in my case, from cancer:

– healthy, delicious food — a bounty of the freshest fruits and vegetables, many like the green “tree spinach” called chaya with unique antioxidant properties;

– climate — blue skies,  sunshine, clean air;

– exercise — walking everywhere in this flat city and swimming several times a day restores damaged nerves and muscles;

– culture — which restores the soul: all sorts of activities especially the romantic ballads of the famous trova music which is the heart of Merida;

and finally, peace of mind – the ease that comes from being in one of the world’s safest cities filled with  friendly, easy-going, courteous people.

Merida and its gentle, wise Mayan way of life is hard to beat.   Not to mention the lack of snow and ice!

Posted in Breast cancer, Health, Merida, Mexico, Uncategorized | Leave a comment

“Speech after long silence,” from Merida again

This blog was rudely interrupted last April when I was diagnosed with breast cancer.  The discovery of the lump came in the middle of the night just as I was about to return to Merida with my husband for a very special week meeting officials and townspeople after my op-ed in the Washington Post last March. The confirming call from the clinic came while we were there.  Margaritas help a lot in such situations, let’s just put it that way.

As I was swept up into months of medical treatment, I wasn’t in the mood to blog. In the summer, though, I went on Facebook and told my friends what was happening.  Why? Because I was having trouble remembering who knew. Some friends even got mad that I hadn’t told them.  Social media was in the end simply more efficient as a way to communicate.  It is how we live now.  And I got wonderful support from my family and friends from both email and Facebook.

Treatment finally ended, hair growing back, energy returning, and making a full recovery, I am picking up the blog with pleasure.  Lots of things to say about a range of topics.

And oddly, I am writing this from Merida where we are treating ourselves to a rare couple of weeks off. I am grateful to so many people here and in San Felipe for a warm welcome and to all of you back home for friendship and support in this difficult year.  Here’s a post this week from my friend Joanna van der Gracht de Rosada’s blog Writing from Merida that you might enjoy, complete with her favorite song, Santa Lucia.

We’ll be here a while longer and then up to amazing Mexico City for politics, art, business and food. So as Hamlet said, here is “speech after long silence.”  More soon.

 

 

Posted in Breast cancer, Facebook, Health, Merida, Mexico, Social media | Tagged | 3 Comments

Back in peaceful Merida this week looking at social capital

Children performing in Merida's plaza

I am so happy to be back in Merida this week, to follow up on the article I wrote about the Other Mexico last month and to meet many of Mexicans and ex-patriates who wrote me with their comments about life here.  I will be blogging and tweeting during the week, meeting with some of the local officials, and giving a talk about the “soft power” of social capital and how it feeds Merida’s special brand on Wednesday.

It’s a beautiful Sunday morning, and the elegant Paseo de Montejo avenue is closed on one side so everyone can enjoy it.  There’s a wedding party starting in our hotel, families coming to brunch with their grandparents, and other families are riding their bicycles, joggers are passing by, and there are preparations for a big walk to raise money for hemophilia. Later we will head to the plaza central to see teenagers perform Yucatan dances and hear some of the fabulous musicians who are contemporaries of the Buena Vista Social Club in Cuba.  I can’t wait to show my husband the Museum of Yucatan Song today.

Posted in Civil society, Communications, Public relations, Social media, Uncategorized | 2 Comments

What’s different this time in Mideast changes?

Author Malcolm Gladwell told Fareed Zaharia on the terrific new CNN program Global Public Square (GPS) that social media role in Mideast uprisings was “overhyped.”  He pointed to successful revolutions that took place pre-Facebook, in particular the fall of the Berlin Wall in Germany where 1.5 million people protested without the help of the internet.  Zaharia’s own perceptive analysis of the past 15 years of changes emphasized broadcast news as much as new information and networking tools.

Gladwell’s right, there have been other revolutions. But that was then and this is now.  I took part in a terrific discussion organized by ICT4D last week at John Hopkins SAIS about how social media was used in Egypt that suggested Gladwell may not be looking at all the new factors.

Analyzing social media in the Mideast,  “It’s not what you see, it’s what you don’t see,” said Amira Maaty of NED.  She was joined by Katherine Maher of NDI and Jeff Ghannam, author of a not-to-be-missed special report on the rise of social media in this region. Ghannam rightly reminds those of us getting giddy about these events that hundreds of Egyptian social media activists were persecuted long before the January demonstrations.

From what I can see, a combination of elements produced this combustion:

  1. Outrageous official corruption — Mustapha Nabli, the new Tunisia Central Bank Governor, and many others have repeatedly and specifically said that this was the spark in multiple countries.
  2. The huge demographic shift to a youthful population — half under 24 years.
  3. Media transformation with widespread availability of Arabic language broadcast media such as Al Jeerza interacting with low cost social media tools that young people understood better than their authoritarian elders.
  4. Breathtakingly rapid events and on-line organizing post-Tunisia – hours and days and weeks not months and years.
  5. The scale of the communication – the sheer volume of tweets, videos, blogs, broadcasts from Al Jeerza and so on overwhelmed the police state.
  6. Finally, smart, dedicated activists and brave citizens who used all these factors strategically to facilitate political events that were impossible even a few years ago.

Which was the spark and which the fuel?  Who knows.  Who cares?  I know a few of the Libyans expats working 24/7 to communicate, organize, influence and plead for a new era.  And let me tell you, they are living and breathing radio, email, Facebook, Twitter and YouTube and of course Al Jeezra.  Did social media make all this happen? No, the people did.  But does new media, including broadcast, make possible the impossible, and at an affordable price?  Yes.  Of course it does.   For now.

Posted in Civil society, Communications, Innovation, Social media | Leave a comment

Bahrain’s Brand: When Moderation Dies

A brand is what you are known for, like it or not.  I write sometimes about country brands, and that’s essentially what I was describing in my Washington Post op-ed about Merida, Mexico two weeks ago – a place that deserves its distinctive, different brand.

But let’s change the focus to another country I know well.  Bahrain has always been known as the “moderate alternative” in a harsh region.  Friendly, laid back, where women could drive and work, and Saudi men “relax” in nightclubs with (gasp) liquor, Bahrain positioned itself as a good place to live and do business, an alternative to Saudi Arabia across the causeway.  An ancient speck of land in a vast sea of sand and water, all it has to offer is a central location for financial and other services and being a nicer place to live. It was where you decided to go when your wife said she wouldn’t live in Saudi or Kuwait.

So now what does Bahrain do when it has ruined its brand?  What is its value proposition?  Even from here I can hear the suitcases being packed, the offices being relocated, the calls from families that have already left, and the inquiries about investment alternatives.  Without political stability and moderation, what does Bahrain have to offer?

I used to spend dead quiet weekends driving through the poor Shiite villages, with lousy housing, fading paint and no air conditioning in a place where summer temperatures can reach 38º C.  I am so sorry, I have no side in this fight, but this horrible political crisis just makes public the reality that anyone who has spent time there knew all along — that this was a terribly fragile situation, ready to break along Sunni/Shiite demographic lines.

And it now has. Humpty Dumpty has fallen off the wall and it will take all the king’s horses and all the king’s men to put him back up again.  If they can.  A brand once broken is dreadfully hard to recreate, especially for a country without other resources.  Which is why it is really important not to break it.  And that’s my point:  the financial price for this political drama will be deep and long lasting.

Posted in Communications, Uncategorized | Tagged | 3 Comments

Questions about “the Other Mexico” op-ed

How did I come to write this article for the Washington Post? Every day in Merida, I had to write an essay for my Spanish course.  This was the piece I wrote on my last day of class, trying to synthesize what I had experienced from mid-January to mid-February.  It was based on walks I took every afternoon with local university students exploring the town, and evenings out. I sent it unsolicited to the Washington Post when I got back, and I am grateful to them for giving me a chance to share another perspective.

How did my views change during my stay? My first impression of Merida’s colonial center and cultural events was that they were aimed at tourists, as is the case in places like Cancun or Oaxaca.  Then I saw the depth of local involvement and participation, and realized that foreign participation, however welcome, was on the margins.  I noticed all the Mexican tourists who come with their families.  I watched people singing along to songs and holding their toddlers up to see the performers.  I learned a lot at the Museo de la Cancion Yucateca, which gave me a new view of the city’s concerts.  As I walked around, I saw many instances of public investment in upkeep, modernization and beautification, in outdoor facilities and fora, and in free events.  And as someone who takes great care when visiting places like Mexico City these days, I relished the freedom to walk around at all hours even all by myself.  As I spoke to residents, their love of their city came through, though of course they don’t think it is perfect.  And I started thinking about Robert Putnam’s writing and other work on building social capital and how it benefits the whole community.

Am I a tourist who wrote a nice travel article? Well, we are all tourists when we are out of our home towns.  I am a longtime international relations specialist, a public policy analyst and writer, and an expert in communications. I’ve worked in civil society, private sector and U.S. government, and most recently spent 12 years at the World Bank where we focus on economic development in developing countries. I’ve lived in a couple of countries, traveled and worked in more, speak French and improving Spanish, and have a masters in public administration from Harvard’s Kennedy School of Government. Nearly 20 years ago, I worked with the Mexican Government on a couple of things including NAFTA.  I’ve been visiting Mexico now for 17 years, usually with my husband. He couldn’t come this time, but in a way that left me more time to observe.  My sister and a nephew joined me for a week, and also had a wonderful time.

Why did I say “we” need to bring peace and tranquilty back to the border communities? All of us who are neighbors in North America have a common interest in each other’s well-being and prosperity.  It’s a much more integrated continent socially, economically and culturally than we recognize in our public debate. Mexicans do need to solve this problem but they can’t do it by themselves because narco-trafficking is tied to US drug consumption and also to illegal sales of US weapons.  We should be helping them in any way we can, and we will benefit if they succeed.  And if they fail, we will pay the price as well.  Here’s a good piece called Five Myths about Mexico’s drug war.

Can I give you advice on where to stay, study, or go in Merida? No, that’s not my role, and there are many good websites and blogs for such information.

Posted in Communications, Uncategorized | Tagged | Leave a comment

Merida photos … and a note to Gov. Perry of Texas!

I’ll be blogging later to answer some of the questions raised by readers of my Washington Post op-ed.  It was also published in the Diario de Yucatan in Spanish.

But in the meantime, here are Merida Photos by Noah Wilson.  He’s my 22 year old nephew and full of talent. He came down to Merida for a week in January. It was his first trip to Mexico and he had a great time, even taking the local bus from Cancun to Merida. Like my sister and me, he wandered around Merida at all hours with no problems.  He loved the food, people, culture, and yes, the margaritas.  His Spanish turned out to be pretty good — hope he goes back soon to get fluent.

I was surprised to hear that Texas officials are advising students not to go to Mexico for spring break.  Maybe they just meant the border areas. Everyone should always be careful when traveling — I am– and that means checking out any location.  But there are lots of places in Mexico where young people can go safely.  If they want to get crazy when they get there, though, they should just stay home where their local police can worry about them.  Not a big fan of spring break American student style.But I am all for seeing this changing world of ours. More students should take the time to do it.

Enjoy the show.  Merida and other cities that work are a lot more than pretty photos, but that’s another post.

 

 

Posted in Uncategorized | 2 Comments

Social capital in the other Mexico…

Apologies for not blogging more recently but I was living and studying in Merida, Yucatan for a month. Here’s an op-ed I just wrote for the Washington Post asking why is it that this city in Mexico is doing so well.  Thanks for all the comments I’ve been getting — it would be great to post them here so we can have a conversation.

Posted in Civil society, Social media, Uncategorized | Tagged | 11 Comments